ARC Review: The Trials of Walter Ogrod by Thomas Lowenstein

TheTrialsOfWalterOgrodCoverOfficial Synopsis from Amazon: The horrific 1988 murder of four-year-old Barbara Jean Horn shocked the citizens of Philadelphia. Plucked from her own front yard, Barbara Jean was found dead less than two and a half hours later in a cardboard TV box dragged to a nearby street curb. After months of investigation with no strong leads, the case went cold. Four years later it was reopened, and Walter Ogrod, a young man with autism spectrum disorder who had lived across the street from the family at the time of the murder, was brought in as a suspect.

Ogrod bears no resemblance to the composite police sketch based on eyewitness accounts of the man carrying the box, and there is no physical evidence linking him to the crime. His conviction was based solely on a confession he signed after thirty-six hours without sleep. “They said I could go home if I signed it,” Ogrod told his brother from the jailhouse. The case was so weak that the jury voted unanimously to acquit him, but at the last second—in a dramatic courtroom declaration—one juror changed his mind. As he waited for a retrial, Ogrod’s fate was sealed when a notorious jailhouse snitch was planted in his cell block and supplied the prosecution with a second supposed confession. As a result, Walter Ogrod sits on death row for the murder today.

Informed by police records, court transcripts, interviews, letters, journals, and more, award-winning journalist Thomas Lowenstein leads readers through the facts of the infamous Horn murder case in compelling, compassionate, and riveting fashion. He reveals explosive new evidence that points to a condemned man’s innocence and exposes a larger underlying pattern of prosecutorial misconduct in Philadelphia.

Genre: Non-fiction
Setting: Philadelphia, 1988 to today

***I received an eARC copy of The Trials of Walter Ogrod from the publisher via NetGalley***

Review: The Trials of Walter Ogrod is a shocking, disturbing tale of misconduct, crime, law, and order. I learned a lot about the American justice system and about the different rules that lawyers and detectives must follow. It was fascinating to read about these details, but also sad in that many times the rules are ignored or passed over.

The Trials of Walter Ogrod tells the story of a terrible crime that happened in 1988 in Philadelphia, and the subsequent manhunt, and the later (much later) arrest and conviction of Walter Ogrod. The book goes to great lengths to show that Walter has been imprisoned unfairly, and the courtroom scenes, especially the first court case, are mesmerizing. The court scene mentioned above had me glued to the page, and I can’t recall the last time I literally could not put a book down. And this is a non-fiction read! I was hooked on the story of Walter, and his history, and I kept reading hoping someone would see what was happening.

From the first court case, to the jailing and second court case, there is a bit of a lag in the story, and I’m not sure that some information isn’t missing. For instance, (and I hope this isn’t too much of a spoiler), but the second time Walter was tried, the defense was handled very oddly, and the reason for this is never explained in the book. Why the sudden shift in defense? His lawyer’s behavior is so puzzling, and it seems like there might be another story there. But this just further drove my interest in the story, and isn’t a negative, just something I noticed and it’s something I’m curious about. But Walter’s story is not over, so perhaps someday more information will be told.

The author, Thomas Lowenstein, has done a tremendous amount of research here, and it is organized in a thoughtful, interesting way. You will definitely want to read the Author’s Note at the beginning of the book, which details his reasoning behind writing the book, and how he discovered Walter’s story.

In terms of what I didn’t like about the book, I must warn readers that it is fairly graphic. The crime is the murder of a four-year-old girl, and the violence is mentioned in detail, along with a lot of language throughout the book. There was also a lot of technical legal and detective information that was fascinating, but also was a bit dry in sections.

I saw this title pop up on NetGalley, and ever since I read Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson, about a lawyer who focuses on helping those on death row, I’ve been interested and drawn to stories about crime and law, especially those who have been wrongfully convicted. Walter’s story is one that people should know, along with Barbara Jean’s story (she was the little girl who was murdered).

I’d recommend this book to anyone who likes to read nonfiction, true crime, books about law and order, and books with powerful human stories. I won’t be forgetting Walter Ogrod and his story anytime soon, and I really recommend this read!

Bottom Line: Powerful and haunting. I couldn’t put this book down, and rated this 4 stars on Goodreads.

The Trials of Walter Ogrod was published on April 1, 2017.

Links to The Trials of Walter Ogrod on   Amazon |   Goodreads

And here’s a link to my review of Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson

Does this sound like an interesting read to you? Are you interested in legal / crime / nonfiction books?


14 thoughts on “ARC Review: The Trials of Walter Ogrod by Thomas Lowenstein

    1. Yeah, I think this and also that Just Mercy book I mentioned have been the only books I’ve read that are about true crime. I don’t know how this book stacks up against others of the same genre, but if they are half as interesting as this one was, I will be reading more! There is so much about the US Justice system that should be brought to light.

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Yeah – it is fascinating, but hard to read because of the violence/subject matter and also the injustice of it all. It’s also hard because it’s nonfiction, and so I just kept picturing the real people mentioned here. It was one of those books where I kept saying to myself “the truth is stranger than fiction”.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. This sounds very interesting. Maybe even good enough for a season of American Crime Story to be based on this. Just think of the many cases that don’t get the spotlight like this one did. How many innocents pay the price for a shoddy system?
    Thank you for the excellent review.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you! Yeah, this was fascinating, and I also kept thinking of all the people that this has happened to (and is still happening to). There is so much that needs to change with the system. It is so disturbing and uncomfortable, but at the same time the more we hear about things like this and the more we discuss it, perhaps change will come someday.
      And it was interesting to read the author’s note at the beginning of the book – he had intended to write a book about the death penalty system when it worked, and then discovered Walter’s story and couldn’t let it go.


    1. Thanks! Yeah it was a pretty intense book, and the subject matter was tough. But it’s an important read and really highlights some issues that we have in the US in our criminal justice system.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. You sounds very surprised that nonfiction can be riveting! Some of the most compelling books are real life weirdness that, had it been in a fiction novel, we wouldn’t believe. This the expression, “stranger than fiction.”

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I know! And yes, I am always surprised when nonfiction is something I can’t put down. I have no idea why I feel like that! And I really do love reading nonfiction. I actually used that expression “the truth is stranger than fiction” in one of my goodreads updates about this book! This book is a perfect example of that, and so many odd things just kept me turning the pages and not want to set the book down.
      I’ve been reading good nonfiction so far this year! This book, Just Mercy, and also I Am Malala. All excellent reads!

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s